CompulsiveCode


Destroy Bates Park

 

This is a link to the City Planners explaining Bates Park.  Planning Meeting Reduces 10 acre park to 1.15 acres, citizens are trespassing.   And below is a quick summary.

     
  One of the planners in the final vote even says "I want to say No but I guess I will say Yes". 

If you want to say No, why would you say Yes?? 
 
 


 

Here's a live view of the space formerly considered part of Bates Park, in Warren, Michigan.  The city is planning to destroy a chunk of this space to build a storage building, 15,000 square feet, 18 feet tall, to house excavation equipment and a SWAT vehicle.  Here we can enjoy the destruction live as both wildlife and people are displaced, and property values come down, all funded by the tax payers.  Say goodbye to the deer and wild turkeys that frequent here, as well as the community and the dog walkers.  Welcome to a future dystopian industrial hellscape of storage buildings, the beeping of construction equipment, and sirens as the police mobilize their tactical vehicles.   Eventually this website will have alerts for SWAT Vehicle Mobilization, etc.

             

Further, the city has clarified that Bates park is roughly 1.15 acres, and 80% of the green space is technically not park space.


 

Freedom Of Information Act documents regarding this proposal:

Freedom Of Information Act Results - Site Planning PDF  

Freedom Of Information Act Results - Vacating PDF

Freedom Of Information Act Results - DNR 1  

Freedom Of Information Act Results - DNR 2

2015 City Parks Master Plan    (says this park is 10 acres)

2021 City Parks Master Plan   (says "adopted" in the filename)

2027 City Parks Master Plan

 

The November 2nd meeting should never have been approved, and should be nullified and invalidated for the following reasons:

 

1. The Lack of November 2 Notices (Postponement vs. Re-Notice Rule)
Under the Michigan Zoning Enabling Act (MCL 125.3103) and the Michigan Open Meetings Act (MCL 15.265), how a postponed public hearing must be re-noticed depends on how it was adjourned:
  • How the City Handled It: At the October 5, 2026 meeting, Assistant Secretary Duzyj moved to "postpone this until November 2nd, a date certain," and Chair Smith stated, "Postpone until November 2nd to allow possible adjustment on the location of the building". Under Michigan municipal law, when a public hearing is adjourned to a date, time, and place certain announced on the record, a municipality generally argues it does not have to re-mail 300-foot notices—unless the project materially changes or the place/time was omitted.
  • Why a Notice should have been sent:
    1. Failure to State Time and Place: On the October 5 record, the Commission stated the date (November 2nd) and changed the venue from the Warren Community Center Cafeteria (used on October 5) to the Warren Community Center Auditorium (used on November 2) without announcing the time or the room change during the motion to postpone.
    2. Material Project Changes & New Evidence: Between September 14, October 5, and November 2, the building footprint expanded to 100 ft. x 150 ft. (15,000 sq. ft.) to accommodate Police, Water, and Property Maintenance vehicles, and the City introduced a brand-new March 12, 2025 floodplain survey map on November 2. You can argue that expanding the scope and adding new departments after the original notice deprived neighbors within 300 feet of statutory notice of the true project being approved.

2. Building Approved Over Unvacated Public Streets & Alleys (PAV260001)
The transcripts expose a major sequencing defect in the City's approvals:
  • The Record: On October 5, 2026, the Planning Commission only voted to recommend that City Council approve PAV260001 (vacating Winnie Avenue, Trembleton Avenue, and the 18-foot public alley). Petitioner Steven Campbell admitted on the record that they were vacating those roadways "so that we can create the partial space to combine those parcels... so we can build a storage facility".
  • The Legal Defect: The Planning Commission approved site plan PSP260040 on November 2, 2026. Unless the Warren City Council formally adopted the resolution vacating Winnie Avenue and the public alley and the parcels were legally combined prior to November 2, the Planning Commission approved a 15,000-square-foot municipal building directly on top of active public street rights-of-way and across uncombined subdivision lots—a direct violation of standard Michigan site plan and lot-line setback ordinances.

3. Floodplain Violation & Unanswered 100-Year / 500-Year Flood Map Questions
The November 2 transcript contains damaging admissions by Planning Director Ron Wuerth regarding floodplains:
  • The Record: When Assistant Secretary Duzyj asked whether the site was in a 100-year or 500-year floodplain, Planning Director Wuerth stated on the record: "I should have been prepared for your question; I can't read it, so I can't answer it". He then added that "we are getting into the 100-year and 500-year floodplains... You've got yellow that actually goes up into the area itself, that's the 500-year floodplain". Later, when Commissioner Heide asked about shifting the building 20 to 50 feet south, petitioner Steven Campbell admitted: "I'd have to have that resurveyed just to verify that moving it back 20 feet or 30 feet that we would still be outside of the floodplain".
  • The Legal Defect: Under Warren's Floodplain Management regulations and Michigan's Natural Resources and Environmental Protection Act (Part 31, Floodplain Regulatory Authority), a Planning Commission cannot grant final site plan approval when the Planning Director admits he cannot read the floodplain map and the exact boundary of the 100-year/500-year floodplain relative to the building pad and required grading has not been verified by survey.

4. Parkland Conversion / Land and Water Conservation Fund (LWCF) Restrictions
  • The Record: During the November 2 hearing, Parks Director Jason Spiller and Planning Director Wuerth claimed that Bates Park is only 1.15 acres along Knapp Avenue and that the remaining 8.85 acres behind it (including the park's comfort station, play areas, and former softball field) is merely "Waste Water Treatment Plant open space property".
  • The Legal Hook: Under Michigan law (including the Home Rule City Act, MCL 117.4e(3), which prohibits a city from selling or disposing of park property without voter approval, and federal Land and Water Conservation Fund / Michigan Natural Resources Trust Fund grant rules), if federal or state recreation grant money was ever used to improve Bates Park or the adjacent fields, the City is legally prohibited from converting any part of that recreational area into a municipal vehicle garage without formal state/federal conversion approval and replacement parkland of equal value.

The FOIA results from the DNR are posted above with the other FOIA documents.

 

 

 

History:

2026-08-10: City planning meeting explaining that they want to build a storage building 60 ft x 80 ft, to store excavation equipment and a SWAT vehicle. City Planning meeting: https://youtu.be/n13H4xr0-aA?t=6750

2026-08-11: City told local news that the new building will only come out 60 feet from the existing building, and be 60x80 ft in size (a lie). https://www.wxyz.com/news/warren-city-official-apologizes-after-planning-notice-sparks-fears-about-bates-parks-future

https://vimeo.com/1217827289?fl=pl&fe=cm#t=47m5s

That is kind of hard to do when the new building will be 100 ft x 150 ft. City Council Meeting:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1mEHUrGhw-E

Citizens were told to attend the Warren Birthday Bash to discuss the parks August 27-30. Citizens were later informed that the park meetings only happened during the day on work days Thursday and Friday instead of the weekend.

2026-09-06: City put steaks in the ground. 100 ft x 150 ft.

2026-09-14: City postponed their decision on this because the city provided the community with an incorrect address for this meeting.

City explained that due to sewer line locations, they needed to move the building further out into the park.

https://www.candgnews.com/articles/government-news/planning-commission-stalls-park-discussion-amid-concerns/

City Planning Meeting: https://youtu.be/woMdVM3aCaI?t=3505

2026-10-05: City planners voted initially to DENY this storage building construction, but then changed to POSTPONE again.

https://vimeo.com/1233491313?fl=pl&fe=cm#t=2m38s

2026-11-02 City clarified that most of the park is not the park. Bates park is roughly 1.15 acres now. City planners this time all voted to APPROVE this building construction. I wonder what changed....

The November 2nd city planning meeting portion regarding Bates Park is below. 

https://youtu.be/ssEIsIfAl4I?t=10

The best part is when the city explains the size of the park, and that citizens are law-breaking trespassers for using their gates:

https://youtu.be/ssEIsIfAl4I?t=455

 

 

Images and Videos:

Compare that with what the city said in 2015: